Black holes

52 CATALOGUED

A black hole is a region where matter has collapsed so densely that nothing which falls in — light included — can climb back out. Its boundary is the event horizon, and mass alone fixes the size: about three kilometres of radius for every solar mass. Nobody has ever seen the hole itself, because there is nothing there to see; every observation of one is an observation of what it does to the matter, light and spacetime around it.

[

THE FAMOUS ONES

] 12 ENTRIES
BY CONSTELLATION · 32 REGIONS
[

THE SCIENCE OF BLACK HOLES

] 4 CARDS
the centre, not the edge
on out past the frame
· 1 ×the boundary itself
· 1.5 ×light can orbit here
· 2.6 ×the dark disc a picture shows
· 3 ×the disc's inner edge
CROSS-SECTION · RADII IN MULTIPLES OF THE EVENT HORIZON, TO SCALE · LIGHT DRAWN STRAIGHT, WHICH NEAR A BLACK HOLE IT IS NOT

Anatomy of the picture

Four radii matter, and none of them is a surface. The event horizon is the point of no return. At 1.5 times that radius light itself can orbit, which is why an image of a black hole has a thin bright ring around a dark centre — and why the dark disc in that image is 2.6 times wider than the horizon casting it. Further out, the innermost stable circular orbit at three times the horizon radius is where an accretion disc has to stop and fall in, and the disc outside it is the part that actually shines.

How we find them

By their gravity and by the heat of what they eat. Stars whipping around an invisible mass give the mass away, which is how the centre of our own galaxy was weighed. Gas spiralling in is compressed and shears against itself until it emits X-rays. Two of them merging ring spacetime hard enough for detectors on Earth to hear it, and since 2019 the Event Horizon Telescope has resolved the shadow of two directly.

What the light does on the way here

Everything you can see of a black hole is light that has been bent, shifted or delayed by it. Gravitational lensing carries the far side of the disc up over the top of the shadow, so a disc seen nearly edge-on appears to arch above and below the dark centre at once. The side turning towards you is beamed brighter and bluer, the side turning away is dimmed and reddened, and light climbing out of the well loses energy on the way — which is why the disc's inner edge is drawn colder than its temperature.

Three sizes, two of them unexplained

Stellar-mass holes are a few to a few tens of solar masses and are what heavy stars leave behind. Supermassive ones run from millions to billions of solar masses and sit at the centres of galaxies — including ours, at 4.3 million solar masses. How the supermassive ones grew so large so early is an open problem, and the intermediate range between the two families is thinly populated enough that every new candidate is news.

[

COMMON QUESTIONS

] 9 ANSWERED
What makes a black hole black?
Nothing that goes in comes back out, light included, because leaving would take more than the speed of light. There is no surface to reflect anything and nothing inside to shine, so the object itself is invisible at every wavelength.
How big is one?
Mass alone fixes it: the horizon radius is about three kilometres for every solar mass. A hole of the Sun's mass would be three kilometres in radius, and the 4.3-million-solar-mass one at the centre of this galaxy is about eighteen times the radius of the Sun.
Where do they come from?
The stellar-mass ones are what a star of more than roughly twenty solar masses leaves when its core runs out of fuel and collapses. Where the supermassive ones came from is unsettled: they were already in place when the universe was a few hundred million years old, which is early for anything to have grown that heavy.
How do you find something invisible?
By what it does to its surroundings. A star orbiting nothing visible gives away the mass at the focus, gas falling in heats until it emits X-rays, and two holes merging shake spacetime hard enough for detectors on Earth to register it.
Has one been photographed?
Two have — the hole in M 87 in 2019 and the one at the centre of the Milky Way in 2022, both by the Event Horizon Telescope. Neither image shows the hole; each shows the ring of hot gas around it and the dark patch its gravity cuts out of that ring.
Could a black hole swallow the Earth?
Not from a distance. Gravity does not care what an object is made of, only how much of it there is and how far away it sits — if the Sun were replaced by a black hole of the same mass, the Earth would keep the orbit it has now and freeze rather than fall. A black hole is dangerous because of how close you can get to that much mass, not because it pulls harder than anything else.
What would happen at the event horizon?
For a large black hole, nothing locally dramatic: the horizon is not a wall, and someone crossing it would notice no boundary. The stretching force comes from the difference in gravity between head and feet, and that difference is weaker for bigger holes — fatal well outside a stellar-mass horizon, and gentle at a supermassive one. Falling in remains one-way in every case.
Do black holes last forever?
In theory no. Hawking radiation lets one leak energy at a rate that rises as its mass falls, so the smallest evaporate fastest. The timescales are not comparable to anything: a stellar-mass hole would take on the order of 10⁶⁷ years, against a universe presently about 13.8 billion years old. Nothing of the sort has been observed.
What is in the middle?
General relativity says a singularity — a point of infinite density — and that answer is generally read as the theory reporting its own limit rather than describing a place. Predicting what is really there needs a theory of quantum gravity, which does not yet exist. Nothing about the outside of a black hole depends on the answer.